
Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District
Best for sightseeing, dining, and history-focused stays in the heart of Savannah’s Historic District.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District is a 4-star, all-ages hotel in a converted 1851 warehouse on West Bay Street, best for travelers who want walkable access to Savannah’s River Street, City Market, and museums. 40 Turtle Lane at The Sea Pines Resort is a 3-star Sea Pines-area villa on Hilton Head Island for guests focused on beaches and resort-style golf/beach access.
Updated · about 36 miles apart

Best for sightseeing, dining, and history-focused stays in the heart of Savannah’s Historic District.

Best for beach-focused stays on Hilton Head with villa-style space and access to Sea Pines amenities.
When Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District wins: choose Hotel Indigo if you want to be within walking distance of River Street, City Market, galleries, and tours — a downtown base for sightseeing, dining, and events.
When 40 Turtle Lane at The Sea Pines Resort wins: pick 40 Turtle Lane when your priority is proximity to Hilton Head beaches, a villa layout with a kitchen, and easy access to Sea Pines outdoor recreation.
Bottom line: both properties anchor a coastal escape but serve different trip types — Hotel Indigo for a compact, culture-forward Savannah stay; 40 Turtle Lane for a quieter, beach-adjacent Hilton Head villa experience.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District | 40 Turtle Lane at The Sea Pines Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Urban historic hotel in Savannah’s Historic District (converted 1851 warehouse). | Sea Pines-area villa in a resort neighborhood near Hilton Head beaches. |
| Location | 201 W Bay St — steps from River Street, City Market, and Ellis Square. | 1 Beach Lagoon Rd, #40, Sea Pines area of Hilton Head Island; South Beach ~0.1 mi away. |
| Size (rooms) | 252 guestrooms, including 57 luxury suites. | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 for primary guest. | All ages welcome; not adults-only (minimum check-in age not published). |
| Pools / beach | No on-site pool; no on-site beach. | Access to a nearby outdoor pool; South Beach about 0.1 mi away. |
| Restaurants & bars | Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom — Southern-inspired breakfast and dinner plus a taproom/bar. | Not published (on-site dining not listed in supplier listing). |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center available. | |
| Known for | Walkable access to Savannah historic sites, riverfront, and event spaces. | Sea Pines location with beach and golf resort-area access; villa with kitchen and pool view option. |
| Wi‑Fi & fitness | Complimentary Wi‑Fi; 24-hour fitness center included (resort fee applies). | |
Hotel Indigo sits on West Bay Street in Savannah’s Historic District within a short walk of major attractions.
Choose Hotel Indigo to be inside Savannah’s Historic District for sightseeing on foot.
40 Turtle Lane is in Sea Pines on Hilton Head Island, close to South Beach and resort activities.
Pick 40 Turtle Lane when you want beach access and to stay inside the Sea Pines resort area.
Hotel Indigo offers a range of guest rooms and suites in a converted historic building.
Hotel Indigo is better if you want a traditional hotel room or suite in a central historic setting.
40 Turtle Lane is listed as a villa with multiple beds, a kitchen, and pool views.
Choose 40 Turtle Lane for more living space and a kitchen when you want self-catering convenience.
Hotel Indigo has an on-site restaurant and bar focused on Southern-inspired food.
Hotel Indigo suits travelers who want a reliable on-site Southern restaurant and bar.
40 Turtle Lane’s supplier listing does not show an on-site restaurant; the unit includes a kitchen.
Pick 40 Turtle Lane if you prefer cooking in-unit or dining around Hilton Head rather than relying on a hotel restaurant.
Hotel Indigo does not have a swimming pool or beach access on-site.
Not the choice for guests prioritizing a pool or on-site beach — it’s a downtown sightseeing hotel.
40 Turtle Lane offers proximity to beaches and access to resort-area pool facilities.
40 Turtle Lane is better for guests who want quick access to Hilton Head beaches and pool time.
Hotel Indigo combines a 24-hour fitness center with an on-site taproom for evening drinks.
Good for travelers who want gym access plus easy access to downtown nightlife and bars.
40 Turtle Lane provides fitness access and a quieter, resort-neighborhood evening setting.
Choose 40 Turtle Lane for fitness access plus quieter resort evenings near Hilton Head attractions.

Hotel Indigo — steps from River Street, City Market, and major Savannah landmarks.

40 Turtle Lane — South Beach ~0.1 mi away and access to a nearby outdoor pool.

Hotel Indigo — Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom provides breakfast, dinner, and a bar on-site.

40 Turtle Lane — villa layout with a kitchen and separate sitting area for flexible meals.
Hotel Indigo — it puts you inside the Historic District within easy walking distance of major sights, restaurants, and riverfront activities.
40 Turtle Lane — South Beach is about 0.1 mi away and the villa gives you kitchen space plus pool access in Sea Pines.
No — Hotel Indigo has no on-site spa, and 40 Turtle Lane’s supplier listing does not show an on-site spa.
Yes — both properties accept guests of all ages; Hotel Indigo specifically lists family rooms and in-room cribs.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·