
Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District
Best for history, walkable downtown sightseeing, and an on-site Southern restaurant near the riverfront.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District is a 4-star converted 1851 warehouse on West Bay Street that suits travelers who want walkable access to River Street, City Market, and downtown nightlife. 536 Plantation Club Villas at The Sea Pines Resort is a 3.5-star villa-style rental in Sea Pines on Hilton Head Island for guests who want villa space and proximity to Sea Pines resort amenities and golf.
Updated · about 36 miles (≈58 km) apart

Best for history, walkable downtown sightseeing, and an on-site Southern restaurant near the riverfront.

Best for travelers who want villa space (kitchen, multiple beds) and to base themselves inside Sea Pines near Hilton Head activities and golf.
When Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District wins: choose Hotel Indigo if you want to be in the middle of Savannah’s Historic District with immediate access to River Street, City Market, evening dining, and a single, full-service on-site restaurant (Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom). It’s a better pick for sightseeing, museums, and walkable nightlife.
When 536 Plantation Club Villas at The Sea Pines Resort wins: choose the Plantation Club Villas if you need a self-contained villa with a kitchen and multiple beds for families or groups, or if you plan to spend time using Sea Pines’ golf courses, bike paths, beaches, and resort-area amenities on Hilton Head Island.
Bottom line: pick Hotel Indigo for downtown Savannah history, walking convenience, and an on-site restaurant/bar; pick 536 Plantation Club Villas for villa space and proximity to Sea Pines resort activities on Hilton Head Island.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District | 536 Plantation Club Villas at The Sea Pines Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, urban, riverfront hotel in Savannah’s walkable Historic District | Villa-style vacation home inside Sea Pines resort on Hilton Head Island |
| Location | 201 W Bay St, adjacent to River Street, City Market, and Ellis Square | 22 Lighthouse Rd, Hilton Head Island (Sea Pines); near Sea Pines attractions and a short drive to Coligny Plaza/Coligny Beach |
| Size | 252 guestrooms, including 57 luxury suites | Room type listed: Villa, Multiple Beds, Kitchen, Golf View (536 Plantation Club Villas) |
| Family friendliness / ages | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age for primary guest is 21 | All ages (adultsOnly: false in supplier listing) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom (breakfast & dinner, bar/taproom on-site) | Self-cater kitchen in the villa; no dedicated on-site restaurant name published |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center available | Not published |
| Known for | Converted 1851 warehouse, riverfront Historic District location, event space | Villa accommodation within Sea Pines resort with kitchen and golf views |
| Parking & transport | Valet-only parking (fee, unlimited in-and-out; one vehicle per room), no hotel shuttle | Free self parking available onsite, no front desk (contactless check-in with access code) |
| Smoking policy | Smoke-free property | |
Hotel Indigo sits on West Bay Street steps from River Street, City Market, and Ellis Square.
Pick Hotel Indigo if you want to explore Savannah on foot and be near riverside dining and nightlife.
536 Plantation Club Villas sits inside Sea Pines on Hilton Head Island, close to Sea Pines golf and resort amenities.
Choose the villas if you want to be inside Sea Pines with easy access to Hilton Head beaches, golf, and resort activities.
Hotel Indigo offers a mix of standard rooms, studio suites, and one‑bedroom suites with historic character.
Hotel Indigo is for travelers wanting hotel-style rooms with downtown convenience and suite options for couples or small families.
536 Plantation Club Villas is a villa-style vacation home with multiple beds and a full kitchen.
The villa is better when you need self-catering space and beds for families or groups.
Hotel Indigo has an on-site restaurant and bar that covers breakfast, lunch (limited), and dinner.
Hotel Indigo is the simpler choice if you want an on-site Southern restaurant and bar options.
The villa provides a full kitchen so you can prepare meals; no dedicated on-site restaurant is published for the unit.
Expect to cook or drive to nearby Sea Pines/Coligny dining rather than relying on a villa restaurant.
Hotel Indigo is a downtown hotel with riverfront access but no on-site pool.
Hotel Indigo is for riverfront sightseeing and walking — not for on-site pool or beach time.
536 Plantation Club Villas offers Sea Pines access and is a short drive from Hilton Head beaches.
If beach or resort-pool time matters, confirm pool/beach access with the property before booking.
Hotel Indigo provides a 24-hour fitness center and an on-site taproom for evenings out.
Hotel Indigo is a good fit if you want a small fitness room and easy access to downtown evening options.
Plantation Club Villas places you near Sea Pines recreation such as golf, bike trails, and Harbour Town nightlife.
Pick the villa for outdoor activity access (golf, cycling, beaches) rather than downtown nightlife.

Hotel Indigo — immediate access to River Street, City Market, museums, and Historic District walking routes.

536 Plantation Club Villas — villa with kitchen and multiple beds for families or small groups.

Hotel Indigo — Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom provides full meals and an on-site bar with happy hour.

536 Plantation Club Villas — inside Sea Pines and close to Harbour Town and multiple golf courses.
Hotel Indigo — it puts you within walking distance of the Historic District's main sights, restaurants, and riverfront.
536 Plantation Club Villas — the villa includes a kitchen and multiple beds, making it easier for family meals and longer stays.
No — Hotel Indigo does not have an on-site swimming pool or a spa; it does offer a 24-hour fitness center.
No — the supplier listing states there is no front desk; guests receive an email before arrival with check-in instructions and an access code.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·