
Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District
Best for exploring downtown Savannah on foot and quick access to riverfront attractions and tours.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District is a 4-star, family-friendly hotel in a converted 1851 warehouse on West Bay Street, ideal for travelers who want walkable access to River Street, City Market, and Savannah’s squares. 505 Plantation Club Villas at The Sea Pines Resort is a 3.5-star villa-style option inside Sea Pines on Hilton Head Island for families or groups who prefer self-catered villa living within a resort neighborhood.
Updated · about 36 miles (≈58 km) apart

Best for exploring downtown Savannah on foot and quick access to riverfront attractions and tours.

Best for travelers who want a villa with a kitchen inside Sea Pines and easy access to Hilton Head activities and golf.
When Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District wins: pick Hotel Indigo if you want to be in the middle of Savannah’s Historic District with immediate access to River Street, City Market, museums, tours, and an on-site Southern restaurant and bar.
When 505 Plantation Club Villas at The Sea Pines Resort wins: choose 505 Plantation Club Villas when you prefer a villa with a kitchen, private patio, and Sea Pines resort living on Hilton Head Island — convenient for golf, family stays, and beach days within a short drive.
Bottom line: Hotel Indigo is the better downtown base for sightseeing, dining, and events in Savannah; 505 Plantation Club Villas is the practical Sea Pines villa pick for a resort-style Hilton Head stay with self-catering and family space.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District | 505 Plantation Club Villas at The Sea Pines Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, downtown boutique in a converted 1851 warehouse | Villa-style accommodation inside Sea Pines Resort; residential feel |
| Location | 201 W Bay St, steps from River Street, City Market, and Ellis Square | 22 Lighthouse Rd #505, in Sea Pines on Hilton Head Island; short drives to beaches and Harbour Town |
| Size (rooms) | 252 guestrooms, including 57 suites | Not published |
| Ages / audience | Family-friendly; children welcome (minimum check-in age 21 for primary guest) | Family-friendly; not adults-only |
| Pools & beach access | No on-site pool; no on-site beach (walkable city attractions instead) | Access to nearby outdoor pool; beach access via short drive to island beaches |
| Restaurants & bars | Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom (breakfast & dinner) and taproom/bar on-site | No on-site full-service restaurant listed; villa has kitchen for self-catering |
| Spa & wellness | 24-hour fitness center on site; no spa | Free use of nearby fitness center; spa: Not published |
| Known for | Historic riverfront location and event/meeting spaces inside a converted warehouse | Sea Pines resort villa living, private patio and kitchen, and proximity to Sea Pines golf/Harbour Town |
| Distance between properties | about 36 miles (≈58 km) apart | |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in 4:00 PM, check-out 11:00 AM | Check-in begins 4:00 PM; check-out 10:00 AM |
Hotel Indigo sits on West Bay Street in Savannah’s Historic District—steps from River Street, City Market, and Ellis Square.
Choose Hotel Indigo to prioritize walking access to Savannah’s main historic and riverfront sights.
505 Plantation Club Villas is located inside the Sea Pines area on Hilton Head Island, a short drive from beaches and Harbour Town.
Pick 505 Plantation Club Villas if you want Sea Pines resort access and don’t need a downtown walkable setting.
Hotel Indigo has standard rooms, premium rooms, studios and one‑bedroom suites in a historic building.
Hotel Indigo works well for travelers who want traditional hotel rooms and on-site services in a historic setting.
505 Plantation Club Villas offers an individually decorated villa with multiple beds and a full kitchen.
Choose the villa for more living space and a kitchen if you plan to self-cater or travel with family.
Hotel Indigo has one main on-site venue, Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom, serving Southern-inspired breakfast and dinner.
Hotel Indigo is best when you want a hotel restaurant and bar for breakfast and evening meals without leaving the property.
The villa provides a kitchen for self-catering; no full-service on-site restaurant is listed in the supplier notes.
Pick 505 Plantation Club Villas if a private kitchen and self-catering matter more than on-site restaurant service.
Hotel Indigo does not have a swimming pool or spa; its main on-site amenity is a 24-hour fitness center and riverfront location.
Hotel Indigo’s selling points are location and historic character rather than pool or beach facilities.
505 Plantation Club Villas offers access to a nearby outdoor pool and is a short drive from Hilton Head beaches.
505 Plantation Club Villas is a better pick for guests who want pool access and easy drives to island beaches.
Hotel Indigo provides a 24-hour fitness center and an on-site taproom for evening drinks close to downtown nightlife.
Hotel Indigo suits travelers who want a compact fitness facility and immediate access to downtown evening options.
505 Plantation Club Villas gives villa guests access to fitness facilities nearby and easy car access to Hilton Head nightlife and dining.
The villa works if you’re prepared to drive for nightlife and prefer using resort amenities as available.

Hotel Indigo — steps from River Street, City Market, and Savannah’s historic squares.

505 Plantation Club Villas — villa with kitchen and private patio ideal for family meals and flexible schedules.

Hotel Indigo — Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom serves breakfast and dinner with a taproom for drinks.

505 Plantation Club Villas — located in Sea Pines with easy access to golf, harbour attractions, and island beaches.
Hotel Indigo — downtown location puts you within walking distance of Savannah’s main historic sites and riverfront attractions.
505 Plantation Club Villas — the villa includes a kitchen and dining space for self-catering.
No — Hotel Indigo is not all-inclusive and charges for breakfast; neither property lists an included spa service in the supplied facts.
Hotel Indigo does not have a pool; 505 Plantation Club Villas lists access to a nearby outdoor pool.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·