
Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District
Best for exploring Savannah’s Historic District on foot, with a downtown restaurant, concierge, and meeting space steps from River Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District is a 4-star, 252-room boutique hotel in a converted 1851 warehouse on Savannah’s walkable riverfront; read this if you want easy access to River Street, City Market, and historic sights. 42 Planters Wood Drive at The Sea Pines Resort is a 3-star Sea Pines Resort vacation home on Hilton Head Island; read this if you want resort-style access to Sea Pines attractions and a self-contained house with a kitchen.
Updated · about 36 miles apart

Best for exploring Savannah’s Historic District on foot, with a downtown restaurant, concierge, and meeting space steps from River Street.

Best for travelers who want Sea Pines Resort access and a house-style stay with a kitchen and outdoor-pool access on Hilton Head Island.
When Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District wins: choose Hotel Indigo if you want to be in the middle of downtown Savannah, enjoy on-site Southern dining at Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom, and walk to River Street, City Market, and nearby museums.
When 42 Planters Wood Drive at The Sea Pines Resort wins: pick 42 Planters Wood Drive if you prefer a self-contained vacation home inside Sea Pines with kitchen facilities, access to a nearby outdoor pool, and quick drives to Harbour Town and Sea Pines trails.
Bottom line: Hotel Indigo is the convenient, downtown choice for sightseeing, dining, and event space in Savannah’s Historic District; 42 Planters Wood Drive is a simple Sea Pines vacation-home option on Hilton Head for guests who want resort-adjacent space and a kitchen rather than a downtown hotel experience.
| Category | Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District | 42 Planters Wood Drive at The Sea Pines Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, downtown hotel in a converted 1851 warehouse; urban and walkable. | Sea Pines vacation-home accommodation in a resort neighborhood; residential and resort-adjacent. |
| Location | 201 W Bay St, steps from River Street, City Market, and Ellis Square (walkable). | 42 Planters Wood, Sea Pines, Hilton Head Island; near Sea Pines Forest Preserve and Harbour Town (driving required). |
| Size | 252 guestrooms, including 57 suites. | Single vacation home listing: House, Multiple Beds, Kitchen, Garden View (42 Planters Wood Drive). |
| Ages / access | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 21 for the primary guest. | All ages welcome (no adults-only policy published). |
| Pools | No on-site pool or hot tub. | Access to nearby outdoor pool; number of on-site pools listed as 1 (access may be shared). |
| Restaurants & bars | Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom on-site (breakfast & dinner, bar/taproom hours listed). | Not published (no dedicated on-site restaurant/bar listed for the house). |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center included. | Not published |
| Known for | Historic warehouse building and prime River Street/Historic District location. | Sea Pines Resort affiliation and house-style accommodation with kitchen. |
| Parking & arrival | Valet-only parking for a fee with unlimited in-and-out; no shuttle service. | Limited parking on-site; front desk greets guests; check-in instructions emailed before arrival. |
| Typical guest use | Sightseeing, meetings, weddings, and downtown dining/riverfront access. | Beach/resort days, golf and Harbour Town visits, self-catered stays. |
Hotel Indigo sits on West Bay Street with immediate access to River Street, City Market, and other Historic District highlights.
Pick Hotel Indigo to be inside Savannah’s Historic District and explore most attractions on foot.
42 Planters Wood Drive is located inside Sea Pines on Hilton Head Island, near Sea Pines Forest Preserve and Harbour Town.
Choose 42 Planters Wood Drive for easy access to Sea Pines attractions by car and a quieter, resort-neighborhood base.
Hotel Indigo offers a range of guest rooms and suites in a converted historic building.
Hotel Indigo fits travelers who want traditional hotel services, varied room types, and on-site staff.
42 Planters Wood Drive is listed as a single house-style vacation rental with multiple beds and a kitchen.
Go for 42 Planters Wood Drive if you want a self-contained house and to cook or spread out in a residential setting.
Hotel Indigo has a single on-site dining outlet that serves breakfast and dinner with a bar.
Hotel Indigo is the easier pick for on-site dining and a full-service bar.
The Sea Pines house listing does not publish an on-site restaurant; the unit includes a kitchen for self-catering.
Choose 42 Planters Wood Drive if you prioritize a kitchen and don’t need hotel restaurants on-site.
Hotel Indigo does not have a swimming pool or hot tub on the property.
If a pool or beach minutes away is essential, Hotel Indigo is not the right pick.
42 Planters Wood Drive offers access to a nearby outdoor pool and is located within Sea Pines Resort.
42 Planters Wood Drive is better for travelers wanting pool access and proximity to Sea Pines beaches and Harbour Town attractions.
Hotel Indigo provides a 24-hour fitness center and an on-site taproom for evening drinks.
Hotel Indigo fits guests who want basic fitness facilities plus immediate access to downtown nightlife.
42 Planters Wood Drive’s listing highlights resort-adjacent activities rather than on-site nightlife.
Pick 42 Planters Wood Drive if you plan to use Sea Pines activities and don’t require downtown nightlife within walking distance.

Hotel Indigo — steps from River Street, City Market, and numerous museums and historic sites.

42 Planters Wood Drive — a house with a kitchen and resort-neighborhood access near Harbour Town.

Hotel Indigo — Five Oaks Restaurant & Taproom and multiple meeting/wedding spaces under one roof.

42 Planters Wood Drive — access to a nearby outdoor pool and short drives to Sea Pines beaches and attractions.
Hotel Indigo — it’s in the heart of the Historic District with restaurants, tours, and River Street within minutes on foot.
No dedicated on-site restaurant is published for this house; it has a kitchen for self-catering and Sea Pines dining is a short drive away.
42 Planters Wood Drive — the listing notes access to a nearby outdoor pool; Hotel Indigo has no on-site pool.
No — Hotel Indigo is family-friendly (children welcome) and the Sea Pines house is not published as adults-only.
Explore how Hotel Indigo Savannah Historic District stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·